From founding slurs to modern smears: America's unforgiving political warfare
By John Toth
The Bulletin
Waking up the morning after the mid-term elections to a television free of political attack ads was a welcome relief.
Many believe modern political discourse has sunk to unprecedented lows, yet, this ruthlessness is not a recent invention. A look back to the very birth of the nation reveals that dirty politics has deep historical roots.
In the autumn of 1800, James Callender sat in a Philadelphia print shop setting metal type. Paid in covert installments by Thomas Jefferson’s surrogates, he branded President John Adams a warmongering tyrant with a “hideous hermaphroditical character.” That’s how electioneering started after George Washington served two terms and went into retirement.
Federalist broadsheets retaliated with fervor, warning that Jefferson’s election would summon French guillotines to public squares and burn family Bibles in bonfire heaps.
Jefferson took the oath, leaving a fractured friendship between two founders that took decades to mend.
Twenty-eight years later, campaigning abandoned whatever gentlemanly veneer remained. In 1828, operatives loyal to John Quincy Adams attacked Andrew Jackson’s wife, Rachel, as an adulteress and bigamist whose marital flaw made her unfit for polite society.
Jackson’s partisans countered, accusing Adams of having procured American girls for the Russian Tsar during his diplomatic tenure. Talk about hitting below the belt.
Jackson took the presidency in a landslide, but Rachel died before the inauguration ball. Jackson stood over her grave with hatred for the men who, he concluded, had slandered her to death.
By 1884, the weapon of choice had become street theatre. Through the avenues of New York, Republican processions marched behind pine torches, chanting in unison: “Ma, Ma, where’s my Pa? Gone to the White House, ha, ha, ha!” They had discovered Grover Cleveland’s out-of-wedlock child with Maria Halpin.
Cleveland told his managers only to “tell the truth.” Democrats answered with “Blaine, Blaine, James G. Blaine, the continental liar from the State of Maine!”
The machinery modernized, but the malice never waned. Outside a snow-choked newspaper office in Manchester, New Hampshire, in the winter of 1972, Senator Edmund Muskie’s eyes watered against the bitter wind. Richard Nixon’s saboteurs had forged the infamous “Canuck Letter,” manufacturing a slur against French Canadians while whispering cruel falsehoods about Muskie’s wife.
To the voters watching television, the front-runner appeared to weep under pressure. His lead evaporated in the drifts, clearing a path for a 49-state Nixon landslide.
Then came the turn of the millennium. In the sweltering heat of the 2000 South Carolina primary, anonymous push-pollers flooded suburban landlines with a calculated poison: “Would you be more or less likely to vote for John McCain if you knew he had fathered an illegitimate Black child?”
John and Cindy McCain had adopted young Bridget from Mother Teresa’s orphanage in Bangladesh. Yet the smear, paired with cruel whispers that McCain was an unstable former prisoner of war, did its work.
George W. Bush surged, McCain stumbled, and the American political apparatus marched relentlessly forward, proving once again that while the names and mediums changed, the thirst for the throat never did.
(Email John at john.bulletin@gmail.com)




Comments